UPSC Darpan

International RelationsGS28 October 2026

US Homeland Security Proposes $70,000 School Fee for Each Student’s OPT Work Permit

Open in the app — quiz, notes, Mistake Vault हिंदी में पढ़ें

The news

Washington. The US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) on Wednesday, October 7, proposed a rule under which universities would pay $70,000 for each new student’s initial application to Optional Practical Training (OPT) and $30,000 for each renewal, Associated Press reports. OPT lets international students work in jobs related to their major during or after their studies, generally for one year after graduation, with an extra two years for certain science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) majors. DHS called the programme a “pipeline for cheap foreign labor” and cited fraud and abuse. It is only a proposal, not yet a final rule. It would hurt colleges that recruit abroad for tuition and tech firms that hire graduates. NAFSA, which represents international educators, said driving students away “will only hurt American innovation”.

The chain in one line: OPT makes a US degree a route to work → it becomes the bridge to the H-1B → Washington calls it cheap foreign labour → DHS proposes a $70,000 fee per student → universities must decide if foreign graduates are worth the cost

Static syllabus linkage

  1. OPT is a work authorisation, not a visa. OPT is temporary employment permission for students holding the F-1 non-immigrant student visa, granted by US Citizenship and Immigration Services. It allows up to 12 months of work linked to the field of study, and STEM graduates can apply for a 24-month extension, so up to three years in all.
  2. The H-1B visa has an annual cap of 85,000. The H-1B is a US visa for specialty occupations that need at least a bachelor’s degree. Its annual cap is 65,000, plus 20,000 extra for holders of US master’s or higher degrees. Universities are among the employers exempt from the cap.

Why UPSC loves this

  1. GS2 asks how other countries’ policies affect India. The syllabus covers the “Effect of policies and politics of developed and developing countries on India’s interests, Indian diaspora”. US visa rules shape where Indian talent trains and works.

Prelims nuggets

  • Optional Practical Training (OPT) is an employment authorisation for F-1 students in the US, not a separate visa.
  • Standard OPT allows up to 12 months of work; eligible STEM graduates can get a 24-month extension.
  • The H-1B annual cap is 65,000, with 20,000 more for holders of US master’s or higher degrees; universities are among cap-exempt employers.

Analysis

  1. The fee falls on the school but will reach the student. Universities pay the fee, but few can absorb $70,000 per student. They will raise fees, admit fewer foreign students or stop supporting OPT. The biggest losers are middle-class students who borrow for a US master’s and count on OPT earnings to repay the loan.
  2. Lens — Strategic autonomy and partnership: India’s talent pipeline depends too much on one country. Because the US is the default destination, one rule change in Washington can upset careers and loans across India. Mobility pacts with Germany, the United Kingdom and, earlier this month, Switzerland spread that risk across countries that want skilled workers. A thoughtful officer would widen such pacts and also build research jobs at home.
  3. Pushing students away need not bring them back to India. India may gain if some talent stays home, but only if Indian labs and firms can absorb it. Otherwise students will simply shift to Europe, Canada or Australia. Since this is only a proposed rule, India should raise it in talks without overreacting.

Possible Mains question

Changes in the United States’ student and work-visa rules expose the fragility of India’s talent pipeline. Critically examine, and suggest how India can reduce this dependence. (15 marks, 250 words)

Model approach

  1. Directive — Critically examine. Weigh harm and opportunity, then judge.
  2. Introduction — the OPT fee proposal of October 7. $70,000 per new OPT student, $30,000 per renewal, proposed by DHS.
  3. Body — US policy raises the cost of the study-to-work route. OPT plus the 85,000 H-1B cap is the bridge to US jobs. Draw a flowchart: F-1 → OPT → STEM extension → H-1B.
  4. Body — dependence on one country is the real weakness. Value addition: mobility pacts with Germany, the UK and Switzerland; build research jobs at home.
  5. Conclusion — diversify destinations and build at home. Engage Washington on the rule while widening mobility pacts.

Administrator's brainstorm

As a Joint Secretary in the Ministry of External Affairs, how would you respond to this proposal?

It is only a proposed rule, so I would file comments through the embassy with data on Indian students’ contribution to US research. Missions would issue a factual advisory so students and lenders do not panic. Over time I would use mobility pacts to widen students’ options.